Track 1 on Classical Guitar Sonatas CD
The opening allegro is in sonata-allego form. The exposition establishes the home key of A major in the opening two phrases (I & V) are the seed from which the melody will be unfolded and realized. The first rises on an alternating bass-chord tone motif of chord tones - 1, 3, 5. Then the sixteenth note phrase falls from 4 down back below the 1 to the 6 - which the falls to the V of the second phrase trying again to rise on chord tones of the V7 - 7, 2, 4 (perhaps a bit more “tentatively”). Then falls down from the 5 down to the leading tone.
Again up the chord tones of the I - 1, 3, 5 - then up again! This time 1, 2, 3 outlining a a rising I - V7 - I. Then another run back down from 4 (this time an octave higher) to a miniature outline of what will be a recurring idea - V - V/V7 - V. Finally a flurry of notes down E7 - a small cadenza ending the intro.
The first subject arrives consisting of a fuller version of the alternating bass-rising chord tone motif. First on the I - 3, 5, 1 - then the V - 4, 7, 2. Then the I again leading to a pattern that alternates the descending 16th note runs modulated for and punctuated by V - V/V7 - V. The phrase starts again but this time changes after the first statement of I and V. This time it moves to I7 - a V7/IV using the 3 as the bass (note this gradual rise continued from the 4, 7, 2 of the V chord). A 16th note run to introduce the IV a D major chord, then quickly a D sharp diminished - as a vii dim of I6/4. Then a little contrapuntal contrary motion to modulate up to F#7 as the V7 of ii. Note also that the melody has “reached past” it’s higest chord tone of the 5th scale degree (this E is a very important point) to it’s upper neighbor F# the 6th scale degree - and like a pendulum that has swung to its zenith it must return down.
The cadence of the first subject arrives as the ii chord is played in two positions with an alternating bass note and scale line motif - first in root position then next in 1st inversion. Next the v chord brings the theme to a close with the scale tones 7, 6, 5, 6, 7 - finally up to the root note and I chord - A & A major. Which also serves immediately as the beginning of a I - V7 - I and modulation - ii - V7 (G sharp minor - C sharp 7 - to the relative minor key (F sharp minor) for the second subject.
The second subject is more subdued in character. It shares the alternating bass note and rising tone motif of the principle subject - but the rising tones are now scale tones instead of chord tones. This leads to a pattern of quickly alternating i - V7 - root and dominant changes. Note also that the melody starts on it’s lowest point and rises - F sharp - which was the highest scale degree the principle subject attained - and then only as a neighboring tone. This pattern will be revisited closely in the development.
The second subject starts again upward but this time is quickly “thwarted” by an alteration of it’s dominant chord the C sharp 7 to a C sharp minor - a minor v (but really the iii of A major the home key “in disguise”). This signals the beginning of the eventual return of the first subject. In order to complete the return it goes through a little cycle five motion eventually winding up on the same cadence that closed the first subject.
Next comes the repetition of the first subject. But this time the ending cadence is expanded. Each position of the ii chord is repeated with gradually increasing dynamic levels (the excitement builds). The V7 is played in three different positions in rising inversions. Finally arriving at the high E on the guitar the cadence backs off a bit by virtue of a B7 and then upto the highest position E again. The function of this little manuveur is to solidify the key change to the dominant - E major - for the development.
The development starts with a bare bones two voice counterpoint theme. It’s essentially a digression on the first subject of the exposition - in reverse. The key is now E major & the A major chord has a subdominant role. Also there is more motion in the bass - almost constantly contrapunctal. The A major arpeggio sweep is a little fun thing that adds a flourishing character typical of my playing style. I also love the use use of the B minor to C diminished to C sharp 7 to modulate up to F sharp major - very Beethovenish.
I repeat the first idea in F sharp but this time modulate up to G sharp minor. I then use the G sharp minor key to develop an idea based upon the second theme of the exposition. First, almost a restatement of the original second theme (up to the high E). Then a repetition leading to the high E again - but this time a fast single note line down through three octaves in G sharp harmonic minor, a D diminished chord as a vii dim of V7, then D sharp 7 the V7. I start the subject again but immediately start to cycle five my way back to the home key - this is known as a retransition. From G sharp to F sharp, B major, E major, A major, D major - quick modulations! Then a pattern of diminsihed chords that serve as vii dim of V - D dim to E7. All the way up to the high E (again!) for a high E7 voicing, falling to a D sharp as the third of B7, falling to D as the 7th of E7. The candenza here is another pattern of fast lines that start on the bottom E string and outline an E7 chord (mixolydian mode of A major!) all the way up to the high E (yet, again!). A more “relaxed” quick line of 1/16the notes down from the D below high E. A low E is the end of the development. The overall idea of the development is an overall motion of dorpping to the dominant key (E) and gradually “rising” back (through F sharp & G sharp) to the home key (A).
The recapitulation starts with a restatement of the first subject in A major. But instead of the second subject being in relative minor - F sharp minor - it has been “transformed” to major - A major the home key! It essentially the same thematic idea recast in the major home key. This is a typical classical sonata-allegro approach. I always thought it was a “sensible idea” and of course admired how well-crafted Beethoven’s recapitulations were. Now having created a “semi-proper” one myself, I find that it is incredibly satisfying to play. My initial idea was to consider following the general form as a guideline but not be “slavishly” just going through motions or “filling in the blanks”. When I got to this part I had an immediate sense of unified “completeness” that I’ve gotten from listening & studying Beethoven (and Haydn too). This convinced me I was on the right track.
After the recasting of the second subject in major the extended cadence of ii and V7 repeats in rising form. Then there is a brief codetta. A pattern of I - V - I - V chord down with 16th note runs down bridging the chords. Finally a last little cadenza from high E down to low A in 1/16th note runs. The I & V chords rise again to high E and once again from high E down to low A in those 1/16ths. Finally a Schenkerian 3-2-1 with the appropriate I - V - I chords to bring the movement to a close.
Happy listening!